We have used many different electric motors in our aeroplanes. Rather than give you lots of detailed technical information, here are the set ups that we have found most succesful for the sort of aeroplanes we fly. The smaller motors are towards the top of the page, with bigger stuff lower down, including suitable combinations for parkflyers. Details of where to get these items can be found on our suppliers page. We are not particularly interested in duration. Indoors, we want to achieve realistic and prototypical performance which is usually achieved by carrying the lightest possible battery pack not by carrying lots of capacity for a long flight. Remember, if your electric plane flies about for 10 minutes indoors you are likely to piss off all the other people who also want a go.
Simon's Small Stuff - Capacitor Powered Free Flight
If you want to make great little electric planes about
10" - 14" span why not try capacitor power? The
capacitor is a bit like a high voltage low capacity cell. A 3.3
Farad capacitor weighs just a bit
less than a 50mA/h nicad cell (about 3.5g) but
it has the ability to give out about 3.5 volts initially as
opposed to the nicad cell's 1.2 volts or so. This means that one
capacitor has enough urge to get a small motor to fly one of our
very lightweight 2mm foam planes such as the Jiglet or the
Flitzer. Total weight will be about 10 - 12g. The duration will
be from 30 seconds to a minute depending on the plane, but you
can recharge in about 20 seconds from three nicad cells in series
(3.6v). My capacitor powered planes are still flying after about
two years of this abuse. The set up I use is the CMS-1 motor(5g),
with a 3.3F Gold Cap capacitor, direct drive to a Union 80mm
plastic prop cut down to about 70mm and scraped thinner, or make
your own prop from yoghurt pot plastic. If you want to go
slightly bigger, say 18", you can use the 4.7F capacitor and
get a slightly longer flight.
Battery Power for Free Flight
The next step up from capacitor power would be a KP00 motor
(5g) and two 50mA/h nicad cells
(about 4g each). The motor can be used direct
drive as above with the Union 80mm propeller, or it can be
supplied with a gearbox and variable pitch propeller allowing
fine tuning of the thrust. Three and four blade props are
available which make it good for scale aircraft. I have used this
set up on a 2mm foam 18" Me.109 and it flies very well.
The main problem you are likely to come across is that the
plane will fly for a long time so you have to trim it very
carefully to avoid hitting the walls or ceiling, which is why we
started using micro radio control systems. Start off with a very
short charge until you have it trimmed out. Electric power is
also great for multi engined planes where
there might not be room for rubber motors in
the nacelles, and you can add another cell if you need a bit more
power, but these tiny motors can be damaged if you draw too much
current from them for too long, so try to keep it below one amp.
It is also possible now to buy timer circuits which allow you to
set different periods for full power, cruise and cut off allowing
a burst of power to get off the ground to a safe height without
carrying on into the rafters!
The sort of planes that will fly on a KP00 motor can also be flown outdoors on very calm days. For larger outdoor F/F planes use the KP01 motor and 2 x 50mA/h cells which is capable of flying heavier planes more able to cope with a bit of breeze - I have successfully flown a 26" span Piper Cub on this set up, but be careful not to charge it up too much or you might lose it like me!
Useful Motors for Indoor R/C planes
There are two set ups that we have found particularly good for
indoor r/c planes. Currently we use the Westechnik Micro 4.5-0.6
motor which ways about 6g and costs only about £5. We gear this
motor about 3 or 4 to 1 on 5 x 50mA/h nicad cells and the KP01
plastic propeller scraped with a knife to make it thinner. This
set up is ideal for indoor r/c planes up to about 22" span
and about
60g weight which are much more 'hall friendly'
than the bigger types. See the Gladiator, Moustique, DH2 and more
on the indoor r/c page for examples of
planes using this set up. By using a cheap motor the money saved
can be spent on a single 2.5g servo for rudder control (you don't
really need elevator on this size of aeroplane). You can use up
to seven cells on this motor but it may shorten its life. We hope
to be able to use less cells in future allowing smaller
aeroplanes by using step up chips to run the radio system at five
volts from a three cell pack. At this point we may start using
the KP00 motor for indoor R/C. One of these chips has been
trialled successfully in my Twin Thing for some time now, and we
are now experimenting with more powerful versions to run the
servos.
Our earlier indoor r/c planes were a bit bigger
and needed more power. For these we used the Westechnik DC 5-2.4
motor geared about 10:1 with one of their carbon props on 6 or 7
x 50mA/h cells. The motor weighs about 10g. Using small ballraces
and 2mm carbon rod shafts a lightweight gearbox can be made.
These motors are quite expensive but very efficient allowing the
use of the 50mA/h cells which saves a lot of weight on the bigger
models.
Park Flyer Motors
The best value motor we have found so far for small park
flyers is the Potensky POT-2A which
costs about £15 including gearbox and
propeller. We have used this in the 24" Corsair, and bigger
powered gliders (like the Caprice) - see the park flyer page for details. We usually
run this on 7 x 120mA/h nicad cells, or you can use 7 or 8 x
150mA/h NiMh cells. Current draw is about 1.2A. This motor is
similar to the Ceto TP03. For bigger park flyers you may need
something like a Graupner Speed 280, which is typical of the
motors supplied with a lot of 'off the shelf' park fly models,
however we have little experience of this as we don't usually
build planes that big (we only have small parks!)
For suppliers, see our suppliers page.
| Type of Model | Suggested Motor | Power source |
| Indoor F/F up to 18" | CMS-1 (5g), direct drive, Union 80mm prop | 3.3F or 4.7F Panasonic Gold Cap capacitor |
| Indoor F/F over 18" | KP00 (5g), direct drive Union 80mm prop or KP geared system | 2 or 3 x 50mA/h nicad cells |
| Outdoor F/F small or multi engined models | KP00 geared system (6g) | 2 - 4 50mA/h nicad cells |
| Larger outdoor F/F | KP01 geared system (18g) | 2 - 3 50mA/h nicad cells |
| Indoor R/C up to 22" and 3oz | Westechnik Micro 4.5-0.6 geared 3 or 4:1 (7g) on lightened KP01 plastic 135mm prop | 5 x 50mA/h nicad cells recommended (7 cells maximum) |
| Indoor R/C over 22" | Westechnik DC5-2.4 motor geared about 10:1 (12g) and 23cm prop. Vary gearing and prop depending on model and ground clearance | 6 - 7 x 50mA/h nicad cells |
| Small Park Flyers over 24" and up to c. 6oz weight | POT-2A geared system (28g) | 7 x 120mA/h nicad cells or 7/8 x NiMh cells |